Pumpkin Yogurt Throwdown

Can we talk about pumpkin? Can we talk a lot about pumpkin?

I have a serious crush on pumpkin this year. And because the universe is kind/cruel, it seems I am not alone and the product gods are blessing all of us pumpkin lovers with an abundance of items.

Photo

Ahem. Anyone want to stage a Pumpkintervention? (Please don’t, I’m happy in my obsession).

While many of the pumpkin-y items aren’t all that healthy or Weight Watchers friendly, there is one standout that I saw a lot of this year.

Pumpkin yogurt. And boy, is there plenty of it to go around.

In the interest of scientific research, I decided to do a little compare and contrast of all the different pumpkin yogurts I could get my hands on. Really, I did this for you, fair readers. #denial

Over the past week or so, I’ve been taste testing one of these beauties every day, and keeping a handy dandy spreadsheet for notes on taste, nutrition, cost and availability.

So, without further ado, I give you my findings, in really gross to OMG order.

Yo Crunch Pumpkin Pie with Pie Crust Topping

This came in dead last in both taste and nutrition. This was too sweet and very artificial tasting. It also didn’t really taste like pumpkin. As one of the only two regular (non Greek/Australian/Icelandic) yogurts, it was also too thin. Ingredients wise, this wasn’t a winner either, with a lot of additives and preservatives. The only thing this had going for it was price (about .55 per 4 ounce cup/ 2.29 for a four pack). But with an ingredients list that reads like stereo instructions and a horrible protein to carbs ratio (3 grams to 25 grams), coupled with a terrible taste, you could give this away and I wouldn’t eat it. Not even with a little cup of pie crust sprinkles on top.


365 Organics Pumpkin Spice

This was almost a tie for last, but it wasn’t quite as artificial tasting. This was the other ‘regular’ yogurt, and again, I found it too thin. I think that is likely due to the fact that I’ve just gotten used to thicker, Greek-style yogurt over the last few years, so now regular yogurt seems watery. This didn’t seem to have much pumpkin or spice flavor. This is organic, but that doesn’t always mean healthy or good for you. This was another fairly low protein/high carb item (7 grams/25 grams). 365 Organics is a Whole Foods brand, so you won’t find this anywhere else, and this was around 1.00 for 6 ounces.

Trader Joe’s Greek Nonfat Pumpkin

20141004_055547

Mehhh 🙁

I love Trader Joe’s almost as much as I love pumpkin. Maybe I love it more? It’s close, at any rate. Sadly, I did not love this yogurt. I wanted to. Other people had been raving about it, so I went in with high expectations. I found this to be nice and thick, but it had a sour taste to it (even for yogurt), and was more spice than pumpkin. This one did have a decent ingredients list, with the exception of corn starch, and the protein is much higher (18g) but the carbs are on the high side (29g) for something not very sweet. Only carried at TJ’s (obviously), and 1.09 for 6 ounces, this one just wasn’t a winner for me.

Oikos Pumpkin Pie

Yumkin Pie, more like it.

Yumkin Pie, more like it.

If taste were the only consideration, this might have won. It was really delicious. On the sweet side, but not too sweet, with the perfect amount of spice, I wanted there to be more days that included this item. Ultimately, this one wound up in the middle of the list due to ingredients (can we please not put corn starch in my yogurt??) and mid range nutrition (11 grams protein/20 grams carbs – I like a little more protein and a little less carbs from my yogurt). This was reasonably priced, 1.19 for 5.3 ounces, and is available at major chain grocery stores.

Chobani Pumpkin Spice

Topped with TJ's This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar. See TJ's, I still love you!

Topped with TJ’s This Pumpkin Walks Into a Bar. See TJ’s, I still love you!

Now we’re getting to the good stuff. I loved this! It was creamy, had good pumpkin flavor, was spicy and sweet, without being too much of either. This also has a good ingredients list, mostly clean, and no corn starch! With a 14 g protein/13 g carbs ratio, this is the first item on the list with more protein than carbs. This is also probably the most readily available, as I’ve seen it at grocery stores, Target, etc. And the price was average, 1.19 for 5.3 ounces. For me, this will totally be in regular rotation.

Noosa Pumpkin

The cheesecake of pumpkin yogurts.

The cheesecake of pumpkin yogurts.

Okay, have you tried Noosa? If you haven’t, I highly recommend it. Unless you shop at my Target, in which case, don’t go there. It’s all mine. Noosa is Australian style, which seems similar to Greek, but a bit less tart. It is incredibly creamy. Made in Colorado, this product is made with milk from a local dairy, and local honey. Awesome. And the ingredients list doesn’t suck at all. Nothing unpronounceable, except the yogurt cultures.  But, let’s talk taste. The pumpkin Noosa is incredible. More than any of the others, this tasted like PUMPKIN. It was lighter on the ‘spice’ element, which totally let the pumpkin through. It had decent protein (14 grams), but high carbs (30 grams). This one had by far the highest calories, and was the highest price (2.39) but also the biggest portion size (8 ounces). The container is almost too big to eat at once, and it has an almost dessert-y taste. My advice? If you’re eating this for breakfast or a snack, have half a container. And then you get some for later! Noosa is starting to be more widely available, but the pumpkin flavor is a Target exclusive.

 

Siggi’s Pumpkin Spice

Hello, new favorite yogurt!

Hello, new favorite yogurt!

Top spot. Or bottom, since we went from worst to best. Guys, this one won it for a lot of reasons. I had never had Siggi’s before this, so this Icelandic (again, similar to Greek) yogurt was brand new to me. And wow, am I glad I found it. This was incredible. Very creamy, not too sweet (bordering on tart, but not quite), it had the perfect (for me) pumpkin and spice ratio. Also, this was one of the only two that had more protein than carbs (14g/13g). But the ingredients list! Short, clean, natural. The pumpkin flavor I could only find at Whole Foods, and at 1.99 for 5.3 ounces, this was the highest price per ounce. But you totally get what you pay for and this worth every penny.

So, that’s the skinny on all yogurts pumpkin. I hope this is helpful in your search! Have you guys tried any of these? Like ‘em? Hate ‘em? Know of another pumpkin yogurt that I missed (don’t even say the Yoplait, I looked for that everywhere!)? Tell me all about your love of yogurt, or pumpkin, or pumpkin yogurt below!

17 thoughts on “Pumpkin Yogurt Throwdown

    • Mer, Noosa is SO good. You will LOVE it. Check out the Chobani while you’re at the mothership, too.

      Ugh. If I could mail you yogurt, I totally would.

    • I too need to track down the noosa. Just tried the chobani. It’s ok. I ate it all, and didn’t HATE it. I have a feeling the issue is really that pumpkin yogurt just isn’t for me

  1. Haha, the only pumpkin yogurt I had tried was the Yoplait and I hated it! Which was such a disappointment because up till that point I had never seen pumpkin yogurt and was excited to try it ( that was last year). I hadn’t tried any pumpkin yogurts this year yet. I hate the thin runny yogurts too and prefer thick ones such as Greek. I had just heard of that Noose earlier this morning when another blogger mentioned it. I guess that means I need to find it. Thanks for the review. This will be helpful for my grocery trip this afternoon!
    PS, have you had the Pumpkin oatmeal? It is Archer Farm brand at Target. It’s $4 a box but it is fabulous!

    • I felt the same way about the chobani pumpkin, Merenda. (Its not thin or runny though- I think the flavor is just not for me. So listen to Bec!)

    • I haven’t seen the pumpkin oatmeal! I will look for that!

      There is supposed to be a Yoplait greek, but I couldn’t find it anywhere. I didn’t even attempt the Yoplait light because I’m not doing artificial sweetners anymore (I also heard it was no buneo). Go get you some Noosa, girl!

  2. I’ve been enjoying pumpkin as a whole this year a lot more as well. I feel like the fall has really come through and pumpkin reminds me of that. 🙂

  3. I’m so with you, Bec, except on the Siggi’s. I’ve tried the Trader Joe’s (last year), Chobani (this morning), Noosa, and Siggi’s. I say Noosa first, Chobani, Siggi’s, and then TJs. I actually ended up putting the TJs in some chili last year instead of sour cream! Siggi’s was too sour for me – I could only have it with granola in it. My favorite is definitely the Noosa. Love all of their flavors!

    • I’m glad you found a use for the TJs. I was so not digging that one. The Noosa is amazing! But too high calorie for me everyday, and too hard to eat half 🙂

  4. I love the pumpkin noosa! Have you seen that they have strawberry rhubarb? I have to get to Whole Foods and find the Siggis. Also, if you buy one unhealthy pumpkin thing from TJ’s, make it the dark chocolate pumpkin caramels with sea salt. Incredible!

    • I LOVE the strawberrry rhubard. The lemon is my absolute fave, and the Tart Cherry. So good.

      I saw those caramels. I resisted. It was so hard.

      If you make it to Whole Foods, see if they have the Spiced Pear Siggi’s too. It’s awesome.

  5. This was the most incredible blog post ever!!!! As a fellow pumpkin-obsessed blogger, I’m all about this! Heading out to the store to get some ASAP!

  6. Pingback: Here’s To New Beginnings! | Run Away With Me

You’ve heard my thoughts! Would love to hear yours here.